How to Cook Steak in a Toaster Oven?

There are many different ways to cook steak, but you may be wondering how to cook steak in a toaster oven.

Toaster ovens can be used for other things besides just toast, so it’s always good to have one on hand in your kitchen.

Cooking your favourite cut of meat is easy with this guide. Read on below for the basics of cooking steak in toaster ovens. 

How to cook steak in a toaster oven? Start with choosing the cut

How to cook steak in a toaster oven
How to cook steak in a toaster oven

Before we even place the steak in the oven, we need to choose which cut to buy. A steak is basically just a cut of of the meat from the cow, and as you know, there are many to choose from. So which one is the best for toaster ovens? Here are a few good choices:

  1. Filet Mignon
    Probably the most popular of all the cuts is the Filet, it is the most tender and have the most taste, you probably ordered it and tried it many times, but you never knew it can be made at home as well.
  2. T Bone
    After the Filet, this is hands down the second most popular. Most people prefer to lightly season it and not serve it with heavy sauces which makes this cut perfect for making at home.
  3. Rib eye steak
    This one is more for professionals as this is a meaty cut which is thick with a bare bone. You need to get the timing of this cut just right so maybe don’t cook this cut in the toaster oven if it’s your first try.

How to cook steak in a toaster oven – step by step

Now that we have our cut, and we can start, let’s see the ingredients and get to work.


  • 1 steak.
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil.
  • 1/4 teaspoon black pepper.
  • 1/4 teaspoon garlic powder.
  • 1/4 teaspoon onion powder.
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt.
  • 1/8 teaspoon cayenne pepper.
  • 2 tablespoons butter, melted.
  • 2 tablespoons flour.
  • 4 cups beef broth.

Here are the steps to cook steak in a toaster oven:

1) Preheat toaster oven to 400°F (204°C)

2) Place an oven-safe skillet with a little olive oil in it in the top rack of the oven.

3) Lift steak out of the fridge and pat down, so it’s not sticking together or clumped up and place on the bottom rack.

4) Place a sheet of aluminium foil over the steak and push it up along one edge so that there’s enough space for the skillet.

5) Add more oil if necessary, then sprinkle salt and pepper on both sides of the steak.

6) Cook for 4 minutes per ounce or 8 minutes total cooking time, remove from oven, tent with foil and let rest 5-10 minutes before slicing into it.

7) Turn the broiler on and place the skillet back into the oven to get it hot again, then pour out any oil that has collected at the bottom of the pan, so you don’t cause a grease fire in the oven.

8) Sear steak briefly by holding it above the skillet with tongs, rotating every few seconds so that it is seared on all sides.

9) Turn off the broiler, cut steak into small slices across the grain and pour any excess oil over it before serving.

10) Serve with your favourite side dishes!

How long do you cook steak in the toaster oven?

A steak should be cooked for 15-20 minutes at 400 degrees. Cook the first side for 3-5 minutes and flip and cook for 5-8 minutes.

Steak temperature guide to know which level you like

Some people love to eat steak rare, some love it well done, whatever you like, you need to know at which heat and for how long to cook your steak for it to be in the right level you like. Here’s a quick guide to help you:

  • Rare: 140F
  • Medium Rare: 149F
  • Medium: 153F
  • Medium Well Done: 158F
  • Well Done: 167F

It’s best to use a meat thermometer to insert into the meat and check the temperature so you can know exactly when to get it out based on your liking.

Can you cook steak in a toaster?

Yes, but there are a few things that can trip it up. The biggest thing is not giving the steak enough time for cooking.

If you cook it too long, it will dry out and shrink more than if you cooked it on a regular stovetop or in an actual oven.

The other thing is getting the temperature right. It would help if you got your toaster oven heated up enough before putting your steak in-and then have patience while it cooks.

Can you cook raw meat in a toaster oven?

Toaster ovens can also cook meats and sausages. Put a few cookies in them when your sweet tooth gets out of hand. It’s a good idea to make half of the usual number of cookies at once.

Can you cook in a toaster?

No, toast is about the extent of what you can make in a toaster.

Can I put foil in a toaster oven?

Yes, you can put foil in a toaster oven. Be sure that the foil does not touch any heating element, or it will cause a fire.

You need to keep an eye on it while it’s cooking because there is no other moisture in the toaster oven to make things soggy if they get burnt otherwise.

Can you toast meat?

Yes. You can also bake, grill, roast, and fry the meat in a toaster oven.

How hot is toasting?

Toasting can be hot, but toasters usually have a thermostat that controls the temperature.

Toasters are designed to keep bread or other foods from being over-toasted.

The toast is heated by electricity that generates heat through electric currents. This process of heating creates toasts.

What temperature is Broil on a toaster oven?

Set your oven on BROIL, always between 500-2000 degrees Fahrenheit, usually around 1200 degrees.

Make sure whatever you’re cooking gets seared before putting it into that extreme heat because then burns will result from rapid heating.

Make sure there’s enough time to cook the entire meal before switching to a different temperature or turning off a burner if one is used for browning meat!

How do you cook a medium-rare steak in a toaster oven?

Cooking a steak in a toaster oven sounds crazy. And yes, it can be not easy to cook a medium-rare steak in a toaster oven. But if you follow these tips, you can prepare your steak quickly and beautifully!

First of all, let the steak thaw for at least 15 minutes before cooking. For every 1/2 inch of thickness, increase the cooking time by one minute.

When cooking on maximum power, turn it down two notches and make sure the food is centred and level: this allows for even heating.

Don’t overcrowd your pan or use too much oil: this will cause problems with browning and crispness.

Pat dry your meat with paper towels before cooking and season it with a pinch of salt.

The meat must be very dry! If you wash your steak or let it soak in water, all the delicious juices will drain away.

And finally, cook on the top shelf: the radiant heat from below will help to give your steaks a lovely brown colour.

How do you broil a ribeye in a toaster oven?

Broiling is a type of dry heat cooking similar to grilling. Food to be broiled is usually quite fatty so that it can withstand dry, high-temperature cooking.

Put your steak on top of the large wire rack, set the toaster oven so that the slot is 6 inches from the heating elements or coils, and preheat for 10 minutes.

We prefer lowering the temperature about halfway through cooking time if the meat starts burning around the edges.

How do I cook a New York strip steak in a toaster oven?

You’ll need to preheat your oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit, then put the steak in the centre of the rack. Please place it in one layer so that it will cook evenly on all sides.

Cook for about 10 minutes per side. Then increase the heat to 450 degrees Fahrenheit and cook for another five minutes per side.

You can use a meat thermometer to check if your steak is done. The internal temperature should be 140-145 F when it’s finished cooking.

What can you cook with a toaster?

You can cook toast, waffles, sandwiches, and pretty much anything else you would typically make in an electric oven.

What meat can be cooked in a toaster oven?

Baked goods are one of the most popular foods to cook in a toaster oven. Turkey and ham pies, hamburgers and hot dogs, pizza and quiche, can all make tasty dishes to enjoy for lunch or dinner.

However, the following meats may not be cooked in a toaster oven: beef and pork steaks, chicken breasts, thick pieces of fish like tuna and swordfish.

How do you grill meat in a toaster oven?

Many people wonder how they can grill meat in a toaster oven. The first thing you need to do is turn your oven onto Broil and set the temperature to roughly 300 degrees Fahrenheit.

Be sure not to leave the oven door open as this will cause the temperature to drop too much, and it will take longer for your food to cook.

Turn your meat over at some point so that both sides get cooked evenly. You can also baste or drizzle the sauce on top of the meat for an additional flavour.


Cooking steak in a toaster oven, while possible and convenient for some people, can be tricky.

The most important thing you need is an accurate temperature gauge so that the meat doesn’t get burnt or undercooked.

With this information, we hope you’ll find cooking your favourite cut of beef tasty and doable!

Also Read:

Spread the love

Leave a Comment